Why Regulating Public Access to Facial Recognition Technology Matters

By: Selena Liu

History of Facial Recognition Technology: The Very Beginning

Facial recognition technology has been in development since the 1960s, and initially, this technology was very manually intensive. In the 1990s, facial recognition underwent a significant revolution and expanded to data sets such as the Face Recognition Technology (FERET) database. FERET was completed in 1998 after the U.S. Department of Defense invested over $6.5 million. The database consisted of 14,126 facial images of 1199 individuals captured between 1993 and 1996 with their consent.

After FERET’s launch, many more datasets and evaluations, such as Face Recognition Vendor Tests, were developed to provide law enforcement agencies and the U.S. government with the information necessary to utilize facial recognition technology effectively. However, datasets such as Labeled Faces in the Wild began collecting facial photos from the internet in 2007, bringing into question issues of privacy and consent. Subsequently, databases and datasets, such as Clearview AI, were created for law enforcement with over 3 billion images to help solve cases involving shoplifting, identity theft, credit card fraud, murder, and child sexual exploitation. 

Potential Downsides to Facial Recognition Technology and Policy Reactions

There are potential downsides associated with the increased utilization of facial recognition technology by law enforcement. These include serious privacy invasions, and differential error rates by race and gender. The latter is particularly harmful, as certain groups are more likely to be falsely accused or criminally charged.

Recognizing the potential for vast privacy abuses, San Francisco’s legislature voted to ban city agencies from using the technology in 2019. Around two dozen cities in the U.S. have followed suit. Federally, bills in Congress were introduced in 2022 and 2023 to limit law enforcement use of facial recognition technologies, impose restrictions on federal, state, and local government entities, and ban the TSA from using these technologies.

New Frontier in Facial Recognition Technology: Public Access 

However, there is a new development regarding who gets access to facial recognition technology. Publicly accessible websites, such as PimEyes and Facecheck.id allow any member of the public to upload an image of someone. For a fee, anyone can access a grid of photos that are deemed to contain faces similar to the image that they upload, with links to where those images appear on the internet. Although the owner of PimEyes claims that users are supposed to only search for their faces, or the faces of those who have consented, there are no controls in place to prevent people from searching for the faces of strangers, or those of people who have not consented. 

Potential Regulations to Public Access to Facial Recognition Technology and Why Does it Matter?

Advances in facial recognition technology have outpaced laws governing its use, as bans, limitations, and proposed legislation found online are targeted toward government entities and law enforcement. Although there is progress in limiting its usage in various states, none of the current state laws address members of the public using websites such as PimEyes or Facecheck.id to identify other members of the public using merely a photo. Recently, a class action lawsuit was filed in Illinois, alleging that several facial recognition companies, including Pimeyes, violated the Illinois Biometric Information Privacy Act (BIPA). They specifically allege violations of BIPA’s requirements for informed written consent before collecting data such as facial photos. This could be a possible legal blueprint to require all publicly available facial recognition websites to obtain informed written consent from individuals before those websites can use their internet photos. 

Though publicly available facial recognition websites do not include photos from social media websites such as Facebook, the lack of restrictions against these facial recognition websites could lead to severe ramifications. Any individual could potentially find out who someone is by merely taking a photo of their face while walking on the street. It is increasingly likely in this day and age that the average person has at least one picture of themselves on the internet through being at a public event or having a professional headshot published on their workplace website. As of December 2022, only 14 percent of adults in the U.S. stated that there are no photos of themselves online. 

As facial recognition technology continues to progress, the amount of photographs in datasets rises. This allows many more members of the public to access data that could help them with stalking, doxing, and finding explicit photos of minors. Despite claims from PimEyes and Facecheck.id that they allow users to request removal of their photos, such removal requests do not extend to the third-party websites hosting those photos. Even if removal requests are complied with, it is unclear how many people are aware of this option as it is not widely advertised. Therefore, it could be almost impossible for anyone to fully control where their images can be used or prevent stalking.  

Conclusion

Facial recognition technology is a powerful tool that could be used by law enforcement and government entities to solve cases. However, it is also ripe for privacy abuse, consent issues, and misidentifications. As facial recognition technology becomes publicly available, a whole host of additional problems, such as increased ease of stalking and doxing, are becoming more prevalent. However, the law has not been keeping up with addressing these issues. 

To combat the problems around public access to facial recognition, states and the federal government must develop laws similar to Illinois’ BIPA and robust enforcement mechanisms. Websites must be deterred from becoming so accessible to the general public or using photos without informed written consent. Facial recognition technology will inevitably continue to revolutionize. Minimizing public access by addressing the legal gaps in laws regulating this technology is one of many keys to its continued potential as a public safety tool. 

#WJLTA #privacy #facialrecognition #technology

Navigating Piracy in the Streaming Era

By: Jack Dorsey

The arrival of internet streaming revolutionized consumers’ access to their favorite shows, movies, and music. It also significantly impacted physical media, media rentals, and  traditional cable subscriptions. In response, traditional broadcasters and nontraditional media companies like Amazon entered the streaming space. Each offered affordable and typically ad-free experiences that made access to a consumer’s preferred content affordable, accessible, and convenient. Whether it was movies, TV shows, music, or live sports there was something out there for most people. These streaming services also reversed the trend of internet piracy. 

In the early 2000’s, internet piracy was facilitated by websites like Napster and Limewire, which enabled internet users to conveniently download free music illegally, causing a sharp decline in music sales. Music sales peaked at over $25 billion in 1999 but were then halved over the next fourteen years due to piracy. However, the emergence of streaming services like Spotify and Apple Music helped stabilize this decline. Between 2022 and 2023, recorded music revenue rose 10.2% year over year, bringing the industry total to $28 billion dollars, with streaming subscriptions now exceeding 500 million globally. Despite this, music piracy remains a problem as traffic to music piracy websites increased by 13% in 2023.

While the TV and movie industries have experienced less dramatic shifts in revenue, streaming options also had an initially positive impact combating online piracy. A report released by the European Intellectual Property Office indicated that between 2017 and March of 2021, the European Union and its member states saw an overall decrease in internet piracy across the board. However, that trend reversed in 2022, primarily driven by illegal streaming and download of TV shows which rose 14% between 2017 and 2022. While there is not a clear explanation of this trend, theories span from the Covid-19 pandemic (studios debuting new shows and movies straight to their respective platforms, enabling easy upload to the wider internet), to inflation, and to the number of subscriptions required to access relevant content.

Online sentiment seems to indicate that people’s willingness to pirate content is driven in part by an increasingly crowded and expensive streaming space that has begun to deliver a lower quality product and user experience. For example, many people find themselves needing multiple subscriptions to keep up with the content they want to see. A Dr. Who fan living in the United States would need several subscriptions to watch the entirety of the series. Similarly, a fan of the NFL who wants to watch every game would need six different subscriptions to do so. Moreover, platforms like Disney+, Netflix, and Paramount + have all incrementally increased their subscription prices in recent years and introduced cheaper subscription tiers with advertisements.
As the tide of piracy continues to erode the revenue of the entertainment industry, some businesses have pursued legal action against internet service providers (ISPs). In February of 2024, fifty music labels sued the ISP Cox Communications in one of the largest ever intellectual property lawsuits. The labels argue that Cox should be held liable for online piracy committed by its customers, and they claim that by continuing to provide service to repeat infringers, Cox enabled and profited from the illegal downloading of music. The 4th Circuit Court of Appeals agreed that Cox had aided in the infringement by not addressing piracy by its customers, but ordered a new trial to reassess the damages awarded. In response, Cox has petitioned the Supreme Court, arguing that the case is part of a broader trend of lawsuits targeting ISPs. Cox claims that without intervention, such legal actions could threaten internet access for all users. While the outcome remains uncertain, if piracy continues to harm media companies’ profits then legal pressure on ISPs is likely to grow, leading to more lawsuits in the future.

Stolen Threads: Intellectual Property and Cultural Appropriation in the Fashion Industry

By: Nayomi Mendez Andrade 

Fashion designers are creators of apparel, footwear, and accessories. Historically, designers have used style cues, designs, and patterns from cultures that are not their own to create their work. This use has often been masked and justified by being labeled as inspiration. However, designers are “more than simply drawing inspiration; designers . . . have long mined from minority groups, adopting their underrepresented craftwork or techniques before passing them off as their own.” Minority and Indigenous communities remain vulnerable to the exploitation of their cultural designs without the proper acknowledgment or compensation because there are limited legal protections for them. 

What is Cultural Appropriation?

Patti T. Lenard and Peter Balint define cultural appropriation as a dominant group taking a valuable element from another culture for personal use, without consent and with a reasonable expectation that such taking will be objectionable. Sally E. Mary specifies that a valuable element of another culture includes “artistic, musical, and knowledge productions.”

The Legal Implications of Cultural Appropriation

Intellectual Property (IP) law is a common legal framework utilized to challenge cultural appropriation within the fashion industry. IP encompasses creations of the mind, which include symbols, names and images in commerce, literary and artistic works, and designs. These creations and inventions are legally protected by Trademarks, Copyrights, and Patents. IP protections offer individuals the opportunity to be recognized for their work or financially benefit from their inventions or creations. 

IP laws fail to protect against cultural appropriation because they typically “exclude traditional cultural expressions from protection.” A prevalent reason why IP law fails to protect against cultural appropriation is because IP laws only accord “exclusive rights to the creators or inventors” of a work. The issue is that the argument against cultural appropriation focuses on the ownership rights of an entire group who may not have directly contributed to the creation of the work. Since no specific creator can be identified, these cultural expressions do not fall within IP protections. 

For most, obtaining copyright protections is not difficult. However, it is nearly impossible for cultural groups to obtain copyright protections for their expressions. To obtain a copyright, there must be (1) a work of authorship, (2) originality, (3) and the work “must be fixed in a tangible medium of expression.” Originality requires that the work be original. Thus, if the work is a copy of an earlier work, then it is not eligible for copyright protection because it is not original. Since cultural works are generally passed down through generations and replicated, they rarely meet the originality requirement. 

Patent law specifically fails to protect groups from cultural appropriation because an invention must be novel to qualify for a patent. To qualify as novel, an invention must not have been known or used by others in the US, nor should it have been patented or described in a publication either in the US or internationally. Cultural designs, however, are often passed down from generation to generation. This makes it difficult for cultural works to meet the novelty requirement for patentability.

While trademark law provides protections for certain symbols or designs, it also falls short of protecting against cultural appropriation. For a symbol or design to qualify as a trademark, it must be used in commerce at the time of application, or the applicant must make a good-faith showing that it will be used in the stream of commerce at a future point in time. The issue here is that cultural designs and symbols are not created with the intent to be used for commerce, but to express spiritual or cultural significance.

A Global Attempt to Mitigate the Issue 

Some Countries have created heritage laws to protect cultural symbols and to mitigate cultural appropriation in the fashion industry. Mexico has been proactive in addressing cultural appropriation in the fashion industry, specifically with regard to the misuse of Indigenous designs. 

In 2021, Mexico’s Minister of Culture, Alejandra Frausto rightfully accused international fashion brands such as Zara, Patowl, and Anthropologie of cultural appropriation. Ms. Frausto claimed that these three brands had benefited from using indigenous patterns in their designs without compensating the communities. Ms. Frausto went on to demand an explanation from the three companies for using the Indigenous designs, claiming that the cultural elements were considered “collective property” of the communities. Ms. Frausto added that any commercial use should involve compensation and collaboration with the communities. 

In 2022, Mexico passed a law prohibiting and criminalizing the unauthorized use of Indigenous and Afro-Mexican cultural expressions. Mexico’s law is designed to protect the Intellectual Property rights of its people. The issue here is that Mexico’s law has no reach outside of its borders because when a country enacts a law, it is usually only applicable to the actions that take place within the geographic region of that country. 

Mexico has set a strong example of how governments can empower communities by ensuring they maintain control over their heritage. Similar protections could be introduced in the U.S. by establishing legislation that recognizes cultural symbols and traditional designs as collective IP. U.S. IP law falls short of safeguarding cultural groups from appropriation. This gap in U.S. IP law leaves minority and Indigenous communities vulnerable to the uncredited and uncompensated use of their cultural heritage by the fashion industry.

#culturalappropriation #intellectualproperty #Mexico #fashionlaw 

Reel Dilemma: Copyright and Movie Content on TikTok

By: Teagan Raffenbeul


Why purchase streaming service accounts when you can watch your favorite movies and TV shows on TikTok for free? It’s no secret TikTok users can effortlessly find clips from a wide array of movies and series as they scroll their For You Page. Often, movies appear in multiple parts, prompting users to navigate to account profiles to find additional clips.

It’s unclear exactly why people are drawn to watching movies in this format. Perhaps viewers are captivated by an attention-grabbing scene that hooks their interest, with the “best” part of the movie appearing on their For You Page. Maybe there is a sense of community created by shared observations and opinions posted in the comments section. Or is it because of the ability to easily skip parts of a movie viewers don’t resonate with, or that they find boring? Whatever the reason, this phenomenon is happening, and it’s widespread, with users having access to countless videos on TikTok under searches like “full-length movies.” Further, tips for users found under searches like “how to upload movies on TikTok without copyright” are easily accessible.

TikTok’s limited upload length led to movies being separated into 10 to 100 parts, requiring viewers to sift through accounts and comment sections to find the next clip. Some argue watching a movie in short clips fails to capture a movie’s essence, leaving viewers to miss the movie’s deeper meaning and fail to connect with the film in the same way they would while watching on a bigger screen. However, with TikTok now allowing users to upload and watch hour-long videos, users can watch nearly an entire movie simply by scrolling through their For You Page. Often, people aren’t going to TikTok to seek out these movies, but they watch simply because the clips happen to appear on their screens.

Despite this phenomenon becoming normalized, providing easy access to pirated movies openly violates U.S. copyright law. The U.S. Copyright Act protects “original works of authorship fixed in any tangible medium of expression from which they can be perceived, reproduced, or otherwise communicated.” Motion pictures and other audiovisual works are specifically covered under Section 102(a)(6). Additionally, owning a copyright in a work of authorship grants an exclusive right to reproduce, publish, sell, or distribute the work and is supposed to provide protection against online piracy.

Movies, clearly covered under the Copyright Act, generally obtain copyright protection the moment the work becomes “fixed.” A work is “fixed” when it is captured in a permanent medium so it may be perceived or reproduced. Copyright protection generally lasts for 70 years after the author’s death. However, movies are often considered a “work made for hire,” resulting in a longer copyright protection lasting 95 years from publication date, or 120 from its creation, whichever lasts longer. This means that any movies users find on TikTok are most likely still under copyright protection. 

Not only are users engaging in copyright infringement when uploading movie content, but they may also be profiting from it. To expand revenue sharing for creators, TikTok created an initiative allowing for longer videos to be posted. The longer the video, the more a user may get paid. Despite the threat of copyright infringement, hour-long uploads acquire hundreds of thousands of views, and in turn, increased revenue can create a strong incentive for individuals to post long-form videos. And with the only perceivable repercussion being potential account removal, users continue to upload entire movies.

TikTok clearly lays out in its policy that it does not tolerate posting, sharing, or sending content that violates another’s copyright or intellectual property right without proper authorization or a legally valid reason. However, this is not a “zero-tolerance” policy. TikTok allows for users to post up to three infringing videos per intellectual property type under their Repeat Infringer Policy before account deactivation. Under this policy, copyright and trademark strikes are counted separately, giving users additional opportunities to upload infringing content before deactivation. Further, the account may not be directly linked to them, allowing users to easily create a new account after being deactivated.

The question is, how can copyright holders combat this? Will studios create positions with titles like “Social Media Copyright Enforcer” where their only job will be to find and report infringing content on social media platforms? In reality, the only real recourse currently appears to be provided in the reporting mechanisms under the Digital Millennium Copyright Act. 

Under the Digital Millennium Copyright Act, there is a “safe harbor” provision for online service providers, like TikTok, to protect them from copyright infringement liability. If an online service provider creates a “notice-and-takedown” system that allows copyright holders to report and request the removal of infringing content, the online service provider will not be liable for infringing content that is uploaded to their platform.

TikTok does provide a “notice-and-takedown” system that allows copyright holders to submit reports of alleged copyright infringement to prompt removal of the content. TikTok, therefore, is not necessarily responsible for monitoring copyright infringement and cannot be held responsible for infringing content uploaded to its platform. 

As a result of TikTok’s policy, the responsibility of removing infringing content from TikTok falls on the copyright holders. However, finding and reporting the countless movie uploads may be a challenge, especially with new videos surfacing constantly. Last year alone, over 8 million content removals occurred, and 80,000 accounts reportedly faced copyright infringement violations. These numbers do not include the numerous uploaded movie clips that remain available on the platform, indicating the extent of this phenomenon is even larger. TikTok’s policy and the proliferation of this trend make it nearly impossible for copyright holders to find and report all infringing content.

Now, with TikTok expanding upload lengths to an hour long, users can upload almost an entire movie in one clip. Not only would this eliminate the negatives of viewing movies in short clips, but it might also encourage more individuals to engage with movies in this format. Additionally, if TikTok continues its trend of permitting longer video uploads, it’s possible that in the future, we will begin to see one-and-a-half to two-hour-long videos. This would easily cover countless movies where the entire work is at people’s fingertips for free. Extending upload lengths like this can further complicate the already challenging landscape of copyright enforcement. There’s a risk that surges in infringing content may occur as more viewers seek access to full movies, making it more difficult for copyright holders to monitor and report infringing content and for TikTok to manage takedown requests. As a result, more unauthorized content might go unnoticed, granting millions of people easy access to pirated movies.

#WJLTA #tiktok #copyrightlaw #movies 

Loan Sharks and Minnows: The Changing Face of Peer-to-Peer Lending

By: Alexander Okun

The financial technology (“Fintech”) industry has created a tidal wave of novel opportunities to borrow, save, and invest; one of these is “Peer-to-Peer” (“P2P”) lending. P2P platforms play as intermediaries between borrowers (usually individuals or small businesses) and lenders. Unlike traditional personal loans, the lenders are individuals who only provide the funds. The intermediary platform then handles the application process, debt collection, repayment. This new model created hope that credit would become more accessible for underserved communities and enable investors to reap greater rewards, while still serving socially conscious goals. The dream of greater inclusivity was rooted in the expectation that credit risk assessment would be fairer and lead to more reasonable loan terms offered to applicants. Unfortunately, this dream never materialized.

NEW MODELS EMERGE

The first P2P platforms in the US, Prosper and Lending Club, emerged in 2006. Both companies promoted new models for evaluating loan applicants that were more comprehensive than those used by banks. This became a key competitive advantage after the 2008 financial crisis, as traditional banks imposed more stringent lending standards for both individuals and small businesses. The P2P platforms’ risk assessment models rely on a variety of alternative data sources, but many include so-called “soft” information like social media, the age of the email address used to open the account, and even the amount of time spent on the platform’s website. Most platforms use this information alongside credit scores when screening applicants, offering access to borrowers whose traditional credit indicators would be rejected by banks. However, expanding the scope of access did not prevent discrimination in the lending process. In fact, an early study found that lenders on Prosper’s platform were offering substantially higher interest rates to Black borrowers than to their White counterparts. It also found that borrower profiles with Black photographs were approximately 25-35% less likely to receive funding than White profiles with similar objective credit indicators. Due to this and general data privacy concerns, many P2P platforms have chosen to make borrower profiles anonymous, even omitting their cities of residence. However, the increasing use of artificial intelligence in screening appears to simulate human biases contributing to the general fear of “algorithmic discrimination” in the marketplace. Seeing as these algorithms are one of the key selling points of P2P platforms, it is unclear how they will assuage public concerns with discrimination going forward.

BANKS GAIN INTEREST

Another key reason driving the hope for financial inclusion was the expectation that P2P platforms would circumvent the dominance of institutional lenders and investors. However, the data show that this was hardly the case; in the United States, P2P platforms are unable to “originate” loans – that is, they cannot make loans directly to the borrower. What usually occurs instead is a partner bank “originates” the loan and then sells the loan to the P2P platform for the remainder of its duration. Although this has proven lucrative for banks and expedient for the lending platforms, its legality is unclear. Some of the largest platforms have thus chosen to formally charter as banks (or purchase a preexisting one). As a result, the largest platforms have begun offering their own loans and other common banking services such as savings accounts, credit cards, and even financial consulting. Even for those platforms that have remained true to the original P2P model, the share of lenders who are banks or institutional investors has grown substantially. What was originally termed “P2P” lending is now but one part of the larger “Marketplace Lending” (“MPL”) sector. Data in the last decade show that this trend has led to more selective lending like traditional banks, even though they continue to use the platforms’ “fairer” algorithms to assess applicants. Some researchers now see the few remaining individual lenders on P2P platforms as passive investors, while institutional lenders act as gatekeepers who evaluate borrowers and set terms. Users are forced to choose between platforms that hide their conventional practices behind the guise of innovation and companies that have morphed into actual banks.

GOING FORWARD
Although P2P lending has failed thus far to deliver inclusivity and equitable lending, there are some public policy changes that could mitigate discriminatory aspects of the lending process. One key issue is that the most advanced AI models are nearly impossible to deconstruct and examine, so it is more difficult  to establish that a model’s developers had the intent to discriminate against applicants. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) has attempted to fill these gaps in our civil rights laws by issuing guidance to lenders regarding their duties under the Fair Credit Reporting Act. However, a more reliable approach would be comprehensive legislation regulating the use of AI to ensure that its discriminatory effects do not spread to other sectors of the economy. The unchecked development of AI models has generated bipartisan concern, and created an opportunity to adopt legislation that better reflects the current state of technology. Until that occurs, we will continue to rely on a patchwork of laws that are ill-suited to the era of AI.