
What is Personalized/Surveillance Pricing?
The introduction of artificial intelligence in commerce has provided powerful tools for both consumers and retailers to maximize their money-saving or money-making abilities. With one click, consumers can price-check a good or service against hundreds of options across the internet. On the other hand, retailers now have the assistance of artificial intelligence to set competitive pricing based on factors beyond general external market conditions, such as demand surges or inventory levels.
Personalized pricing, or what critics call “surveillance pricing,” is a pricing model driven not by the external market, but by the collection and use of consumers’ personal data, such as location, income, demographics, or web-browsing habits, to infer each customer’s maximum willingness to pay.
This can result in different prices being offered to different customers for the same product, from the same retailer, at the same time of day. In an NBC News experiment, nine people simultaneously attempted to purchase the same seat on the same night of a Harry Styles concert and received eight different prices ranging from $455 to $517. In one test conducted within Consumer Reports’ 2025 investigation into Instacart, a sample of Seattle shoppers simultaneously checked out identical baskets of goods from the same Safeway and saw a roughly 8.4% difference between the highest- and lowest-priced baskets.
Consumer advocates warn that without more transparency, algorithms may be leveraging personal information unscrupulously to achieve maximum profits at the expense of consumers. However, some studies have suggested that personalized pricing schemes may not be as pervasive as consumers fear and may benefit consumers by providing enhanced discounts, expanding access to goods, and increasing competition amongst sellers. Professor Z. John Zhang of the University of Pennsylvania’s Wharton School of Business cautions that before legislators jump to outright bans on personalized pricing, they should consider balancing the “visible unfairness of price variation” with the “invisible unfairness of exclusion.”
Public Policy Response to Personalized Pricing
The U.S. lacks comprehensive federal laws covering privacy, data protection, and artificial intelligence. Therefore, Section 5 of the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) Act, which prohibits “unfair or deceptive acts or practices in or affecting commerce,” is the federal statutory provision best equipped to set guardrails around personalized pricing schemes. The FTC is actively investigating the use of personal data to set prices to inform its policy stance.
The regulatory power of the FTC, however, is limited to requiring transparency in commercial practices. Therefore, companies may be able to continue personalized pricing so long as they disclose their practices. Retailers are testing the bounds of this regulatory strategy by presenting First and Fourteenth Amendment arguments to push back against a New York state law that requires the scripted disclosure, “This price was set by an algorithm using your personal data,” on each affected product.
Additionally, in the absence of federal regulation, many states and cities have started enacting their own laws addressing the practice. In October, Seattle became the first city in the country to ban personalized pricing when Mayor Katie Wilson signed the Fair Pricing and Transparency Ordinance.
Legal Implications of Seattle’s Ban on “Algorithmic Price Discrimination”
Seattle’s Fair Pricing and Transparency Ordinance takes effect on September 1, 2027, and will prohibit delivery service providers, mixed-use grocery businesses, and grocery businesses with 20 or more retail locations globally from practicing “algorithmic price discrimination.”
The ordinance’s broad definition of “algorithmic price discrimination” is “setting, altering, or manipulating the price of goods offered to a consumer or a segment of consumers based in whole or in part on monitoring, tracking, or automated analysis of the consumer’s behavior, location, demographic characteristics, biometric data, or other personal information.” This definition includes:
- Any personal information a retailer acquires from a third party;
- Any personal information a retailer collects using electronic surveillance technology (e.g., sensors, cameras, and other technologies that may be used to identify and track people or devices, collect biometric information, and gather personal data); and
- Offering random variations in prices to different consumers.
The ordinance language raises several legal implications for retailers and consumers to consider as it goes into effect later next year.
Despite the broad definition of “algorithmic price discrimination,” the ordinance includes a list of specific exceptions. Some critics argue the scope implies that the only pricing schemes that will remain legal after the ordinance goes into effect will be the ones exempted, stifling innovation. Further, there may be future legal challenges over the language of exempt pricing schemes. One carveout exempts rewards programs where discounted prices are based on prior purchase history of “tiers or groupings” of consumers rather than individuals without concretely defining how many people may comprise a “tier or group.”
The ordinance also broadly defines an “aggrieved party” as a “consumer or other person who suffers tangible or intangible harm” due to a violation. What constitutes “tangible or intangible harm” under the ordinance, and who qualifies as an “other person” aside from a consumer? Since the law creates a private right of action, this ordinance may pave the way for class action suits inclusive of plaintiffs who had never purchased an affected product from, or perhaps had never even shopped at, a defendant retailer at all.
Finally, the ordinance attempts to close contractual loopholes by voiding “any waiver by an individual of any provision” of the ordinance as contrary to public policy. This waiver provision appears poised to address concerns that companies could bury a consent agreement to personalized pricing in a lengthy terms-of-service contract. Under the ordinance, retailers would not be able to rely on a defense that the consumer agreed to their personal data being used to set a personalized price.
In response to Seattle’s Fair Pricing and Transparency Ordinance, some advocates from Washington’s business community have voiced concern that retailers may be incentivized to eliminate or reduce rewards programs due to high legal risk, which may, in turn, increase average grocery prices. The ultimate consequences of this new ordinance remain to be seen, but the debate over how Seattle should regulate personalized pricing reflects the struggle local lawmakers across the country face as they balance consumer privacy concerns with the potential economic benefits of artificial intelligence. In the absence of comprehensive federal guidance, national retailers will be expected to navigate and remain in compliance with varying and potentially conflicting rules across jurisdictions.
#SurveillancePricing #ConsumerPrivacy #AIRegulation #WJLTA