Can You Protect Grandma’s Secret Sauce Recipe? IP Protecting Culinary Innovation

By: Santi Pedraza Arenas

Grandma’s pride and joy isn’t her grandchildren—it’s her pasta sauce, a cherished recipe passed down through generations. With a determined spirit, she refuses to share it with anyone outside the family. But when she accidentally posts the recipe online, her culinary treasure is suddenly at risk. How can we protect Grandma’s secret sauce from being stolen and used by the masses?

In the culinary world, creativity drives innovation, from secret recipes to unique plating. But how do intellectual property (IP) laws come into play to safeguard these efforts? While food might seem outside IP’s traditional scope, various legal protections—including trade secrets, copyrights, and patents—can help grandmas, chefs, and food companies protect their delicious creations. This blog explores how IP law intersects with the food industry, and the tools available to chefs and food companies to protect their creations.

Recipes and Copyright: Functional or Creative Works? 

Copyright law is designed to protect original works, but recipes often fall into a legal gray area. Typically, recipes are viewed as functional works because they consist of lists of ingredients and instructions aimed at producing a dish. This functional nature means that they generally do not qualify for copyright protection. Because recipes primarily guide the preparation and cooking process rather than expressing artistic creativity, they typically do not meet the criteria for copyright protection. However, some recipes may qualify for protection if they contain elements of creative expression. For example, while a basic list of ingredients and instructions would not meet copyright standards, a recipe that weaves in storytelling, personal anecdotes, or cultural significance may be eligible. 

The case of Publications Int’l Ltd. v. Meredith Corp. further explores this issue. The court ruled that recipes could receive copyright protection only if they showcase creative expression beyond their functional components. This ruling emphasizes that a recipe can be more than just a set of instructions; it can incorporate storytelling, cultural context, and personal narratives that elevate it into an artistic domain. For chefs, this legal precedent provides a means to protect not only the technical details of their culinary creations but also the unique stories that enhance their dishes. By integrating these creative elements, chefs can safeguard the overall experience of their culinary offerings, making it harder for others to replicate the essence of what makes their dishes distinctive.

Plating and Presentation: Food as an Artistic Expression. 

In the age of social media, how food looks on the plate is almost as important as how it tastes. But can the art of food presentation, or “plating,” be protected under IP law? Though chefs are increasingly recognized as artists, current copyright laws don’t explicitly protect food presentation. The intricate designs chefs create on plates can be considered art forms, due to the use of color, size, and texture on a plate that serves as a canvas. However, there is no clear legal precedent for copyright protection in this area.

Trade Secrets: A Common Solution for Culinary Creations.

One of the most common ways chefs and food companies protect their valuable creations is through trade secrets. A trade secret is confidential business information that gives a company a competitive edge, such as a recipe, formula, or process. Some of the most famous recipes in the world, like the formula for Coca-Cola or KFC’s secret blend of herbs and spices, are protected as trade secrets. Unlike copyright, which requires public disclosure, trade secrets remain protected as long as they are kept confidential.

Smaller restaurants can also benefit from trade secret protection. A family-run restaurant, for instance, can safeguard a secret sauce recipe by ensuring that the recipe is not generally known, provides some sort of economic gain, and has been protected from public knowledge. However, keeping recipes secret can be challenging as advances in food technology make reverse engineering more common.

Patents in the Culinary World: When Technology Meets Food.

Patents, though rare in the food industry, can apply to innovative cooking methods or technology. A patent is a legal right granted to an inventor that allows them to exclude others from making, using, or selling their invention for a certain period of time. For example, molecular gastronomy—a style of cooking that blends food science with culinary arts to create new textures and flavors—offers unique patentable techniques. Chef Homaro Cantu patented his technique of printing edible images on flavored paper. These kinds of inventions are unique in that they combine food with science, creating patentable methods that go beyond typical recipes.

That said, for most chefs, pursuing patents is not practical. Patents are expensive, time-consuming, and have strict novelty requirements, which makes them difficult to pursue for chefs who build on existing culinary traditions. Only groundbreaking inventions, like new food processing techniques, typically qualify for patents.

Trade Dress: Protecting the Look and Feel of Culinary Creations. 

Trade dress offers another form of protection, particularly for restaurant plating. Trade dress, a subset of trademark law, protects the distinctive look or packaging of a product. In the food industry, this can apply to a restaurant’s signature dish or unique packaging.

For example, a dish with a distinctive presentation could qualify for trade dress protection if it’s recognizable and identifies the creator. Trade dress protection is useful in cases where the presentation of the food itself becomes a part of the brand’s identity​. However, trade dress protection only applies if the presentation is both distinctive and non-functional, meaning it cannot merely serve a practical purpose like making the food easier to eat. This limits the application of trade dress protections to truly unique and artistic presentations.

Conclusion 

As the culinary industry continues to evolve, chefs and restaurateurs are increasingly turning to IP law to protect their creative efforts. While copyright offers limited protection for recipes, those incorporating creative expression may qualify. Food presentation, though currently outside of traditional copyright protection, may gain legal recognition as the line between art and food continues to blur. 

In the meantime, trade secrets, patents, and trade dress offer practical ways for chefs to protect their culinary innovations. By understanding how IP law applies to the food industry, chefs and restaurateurs can better protect their work while continuing to innovate. As competition in the culinary world grows, so too will the need for chefs to explore these legal protections and safeguard their unique creations.

#WJLTA #UWLAW #IPLAW #CulinaryInnovation #LegalFlavors

Ready, Set, Go: Navigating the Race to Trademark on Social Media

By: Penny Pathanaporn 

With the rise of fast-paced social media platforms like TikTok, it’s no surprise that viral trends come and go just as swiftly. For example, in May 2023, a controversial viral trend called “Girl Dinner” circulated all over TikTok. Across many social media platforms, users documented meals consisting of an arbitrary combination of leftovers and snacks, dubbing them “Girl Dinner.” 

This past June, another viral trend—“Brat Summer”—emerged following the release of Charli XCX’s album “Brat.” Users across social media platforms used the term “Brat Summer” to describe an aesthetic or a lifestyle that embraces bold self-expression, a trait endorsed by Charli XCX herself. 

On the surface, viral trends may appear trivial. Social media users might derive joy from participating in these trends without much thought about who actually created them or whether they can even be owned. But, in reality, creators of viral trends are often faced with an uphill battle of obtaining legal protection for their creations through trademarks. Trademarks, which are words, symbols, or designs used to identify goods, help prevent other people from profiting off a creator’s work without permission and from tainting the reputation of a creator’s brand. 

The Latest Viral Trend: “Very Demure, Very Mindful”

This past summer, TikTok creator Jools Lebron created a viral trend known as “Very Demure, Very Mindful.” On August 2, 2024, Lebron published a TikTok video titled “How To Be Demure at Work.” In the video, which has now amassed more than 52 million views, Lebron states: “You see how I come to work? Very demure . . . I do my makeup . . . I do a little braid . . . Very demure. Very mindful.”  

Following her first video, Lebron documented herself engaging in ordinary activities that she describes as “demure” and “mindful,” such as going to the salon or deboarding a plane. Although these terms are initially equated with endearment or modesty, as the trend caught on, TikTok users began using the terms in a more ironic fashion. 

Despite the virality of her videos, Lebron soon faced issues with obtaining legal protection for her work. On August 20, 2024, a man named Jefferson Bates, who did not create the “Very Demure Very Mindful” trend, submitted a trademark application for the phrase at the United States Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO). 

On August 29, 2024, Lebron rushed to file a trademark application for her viral creation at the USPTO. However, by that point, at least three other people had already submitted trademark applications for the very same catchphrase. Like Bates, these individuals did not create the “Very Demure Very Mindful” trend. 

U.S. Trademark Law: A Silver Lining 

There is still a silver lining for Lebron. Although just about anyone can file a trademark application for a phrase at the USPTO, filing an application does not guarantee ownership over the trademark. 

First, for a phrase to be successfully registered as a trademark, the registrant must use the phrase for a commercial purpose. For example, if an individual uses the phrase on a product or ties the phrase to a service, this can qualify as commercial usage. Under U.S. trademark law, those who first utilized a phrase for a commercial purpose may be able to amass trademark rights and have priority over those who first filed a trademark application.  

After going viral, Lebron partnered with multiple companies such as Lyft and Verizon, using her viral catchphrase to help promote these famous brands. These partnerships may work in Lebron’s favor in her fight to trademark the catchphrase since these brand deals could be evidence of commercial use. 

Second, the USPTO can reject trademark applications based on false associations. In other words, if the phrase that has been applied for is falsely connected with a person, the application may not be approved. For example, the Trademark Trial and Appeal Board denied Bang Energy’s application to trademark the words “Purple Rain” due to its false association with the artist Prince. Prince’s album “Purple Rain” is so culturally significant that the general public would automatically associate the words “Purple Rain” with the artist’s brand rather than Bang Energy. 

Like the Bang Energy case, there is a possibility that trademark applications for “Very Demure, Very Mindful” may be rejected. Lebron’s legal team may be able to argue that, because the public strongly associates Lebron’s identity with the “Very Demure, Very Mindful” trend, permitting individuals like Bates to trademark the catchphrase would fall under the false association doctrine.  

Afterall, unlike the “Girl Dinner” trend—which saw social media users partaking in the trend without associating the creator with the catchphrase—Lebron became the face for the “Very Demure, Very Mindful” movement. Lebron even appeared as a guest on Jimmy Kimmel live to promote her catchphrase, and was invited to attend the Democratic National Convention, most likely due to her popularity amongst the younger generation. 

Lastly, under U.S. trademark law, the USPTO can also reject trademark applications for phrases that are “widely used message[s]” and are not directly related to the applicant. Lebron’s trademark application could be successful since TikTok users seem to consider the viral catchphrase “Very Demure, Very Mindful” to be a part of Lebron’s personal brand. Nevertheless, the USPTO has the final say and may ultimately render a decision that could swing either way. 

Implications of the Race to Trademark in the Online World 

Although Lebron has a strong case against the individuals who have attempted to trademark her creation, Lebron’s struggle to hold on to something that should have already been hers represents a problem that many small creators face. Small creators typically lack the legal knowledge and resources to know when to take swift action to protect their work and profit from their own creations.  

Despite the silliness of viral trends, these creators still deserve legal recognition and protection for their work. For Lebron, her catchphrase represents a life-changing miracle. Because of her newfound success resulting from the “Very Demure, Very Mindful” trend, she was able to “finance the rest of [her] transition.” Accordingly, it is important for small creators and influencers to be educated on the rights that they have to their online content, which for many is how they ultimately earn a living.  

A Comparative Analysis of AI Governance Frameworks

By Audrey Zhang Yang

Introduction

The advent of artificial intelligence (AI) has prompted nations around the globe to develop governance frameworks to ensure the ethical, secure, and beneficial deployment of AI technologies. This paper presents a comparative analysis of AI governance frameworks across five key regions: the European Union, the United Kingdom, the United States, China, and Singapore. Each region has adopted a unique approach, reflecting its cultural values, legal traditions, and strategic priorities. By examining these frameworks, we can discern the varying priorities and methods of regulation that influence the global AI landscape.

European Union

The EU stands at the forefront of AI regulation with its Artificial Intelligence Act (AI Act), a pioneering legislative effort to categorize and manage AI systems based on their risk levels. The Act delineates four categories of risk: unacceptable, high, medium, and low, with prohibitions on certain AI applications deemed contrary to EU values, such as social scoring and manipulative practices. This regulatory framework is complemented by existing product liability directives, technical standards, and conventions addressing AI’s impact on human rights. Collectively, these measures embody the EU’s commitment to a human-centric AI that aligns with its democratic values and social norms.

United Kingdom

The UK’s AI governance is articulated through five guiding principles that emphasize safety, transparency, fairness, accountability, and the right to redress. Regulatory oversight is distributed among existing agencies, with the Information Commissioner’s Office overseeing data privacy and the Competition and Markets Authority addressing competition-related issues. The UK’s approach integrates AI governance within the existing legal and regulatory framework, ensuring that AI systems are developed and used in a manner consistent with established norms and standards.

United States 

In contrast, the US has adopted a more decentralized and sector-specific approach to AI governance. The recent executive order by President Biden sets forth a national strategy, delegating responsibilities to various federal agencies. The Department of Commerce’s National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST), Bureau of Industry and Security (BIS), National Telecommunications and Information Administration (NTIA), and U.S. Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) play pivotal roles in this strategy. The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) has been active in addressing the misuse of biometric data, while the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) have focused on the implications of AI in their respective domains. United States Department of Health and Human Services’ (HHS) regulations on AI in healthcare mark a significant step in sector-specific governance. At the state level, legislation such as Illinois’ Biometric Information Privacy Act (BIPA), California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA), and California Privacy Rights Act (CPRA) demonstrate a proactive stance on privacy and consumer rights. The US model is characterized by a patchwork of laws and regulations that, together with court precedents and other governance frameworks, shape the AI regulatory environment.

China

China’s approach to AI governance is tightly linked to its broader data security and privacy regime. The Cybersecurity Law, Data Security Law, and Personal Information Protection Law form the backbone of AI regulation, with additional policy documents guiding the AI industry’s development. The Interim Measures for the Management of Generative Artificial Intelligence Services represent a targeted regulatory effort to oversee AI-generated content. China’s strategy reflects its centralized governance model and its ambition to become a leader in AI while maintaining strict control over data and technology.

Singapore

Singapore’s AI governance framework is characterized by its non-mandatory nature, focusing on guidelines, testing frameworks, and toolkits to promote best practices in AI adoption. This approach has created a business-friendly environment that encourages innovation and attracts companies seeking a more flexible regulatory landscape. Singapore’s model demonstrates a balance between fostering AI development and ensuring responsible use through voluntary compliance with government-endorsed guidelines.

Conclusion

The comparative analysis of AI governance frameworks across the EU, UK, US, China, and Singapore underscores the multifaceted nature of AI regulation and the diverse philosophies underpinning it. The EU’s Artificial Intelligence Act represents a step towards a comprehensive, risk-based regulatory regime, setting a precedent for future legislation with its categorization of AI applications and emphasis on fundamental rights and values. This contrasts with the US’s decentralized, sector-specific approach, which relies on a mosaic of federal and state regulations, agency guidelines, and industry standards to govern the AI landscape. The US system’s flexibility allows for rapid adaptation to technological advancements but may result in a less cohesive regulatory environment.

China’s centralized governance model integrates AI regulation within its broader data security framework, reflecting its strategic intent to harness AI’s potential while enforcing stringent data control measures. This approach facilitates a coordinated and consistent policy environment but may also impose rigid constraints on AI innovation and usage. Singapore, on the other hand, has crafted a non-mandatory, guidelines-based framework that prioritizes industry growth and agility. By promoting voluntary adherence to best practices, Singapore positions itself as a hub for AI development, though this flexibility might pose challenges in ensuring accountability and ethical compliance.

The UK’s governance framework, guided by principles of safety, transparency, and fairness, seeks to embed AI regulation within its existing legal and regulatory structures. This principle-driven approach aims to ensure that AI development aligns with societal norms and provides mechanisms for redress, yet it may require continuous updates to keep pace with the rapid evolution of AI technologies.

In conclusion, the examination of these diverse governance frameworks reveals that there is no one-size-fits-all approach to AI regulation. Each model reflects the region’s cultural, legal, and strategic priorities, and each comes with its own set of trade-offs. As AI technologies continue to advance and permeate various aspects of society, these governance frameworks will need to evolve, balancing the promotion of innovation with the protection of public interests. The ongoing dialogue of suitable practices among these regions will be crucial in shaping a global AI governance landscape that is both dynamic and responsible.

Trouble on the Beach

By: Drew Carlson

This June, Jacksonville Florida will host the Orange Crush Festival. However, some businesses may be celebrating it not with festivities, but with a lawsuit.

The “‘culturally historic’ festival is a loosely organized three-day beach weekend that draws a largely Black college-age crowd.” The festival has already been held in Miami as well as Tybee Island this year, and is scheduled to be held in Miami again on May 24-27 and in Jacksonville on June 11-14. During these festivals many businesses often host their own Orange Crush themed events, but due to trademark law, their free-riding may soon come to a sudden stop.

The name “Orange Crush Festival” is trademarked by George Ransom Turner III. On April 15, George Turner sent out five cease-and-desist letters ordering people and businesses to stop using his trademark. According to Turner, this action was necessary because of the damage these unofficial festival events have wrought on both his personal and company’s reputation. 

Turner considers these businesses “piggyback promoters” and claims that his business has been blamed for their problems. In a recent interview Turner said that, “[t]he negative media and the negative backlash and all of the things that went really bad last year on the beach that I was nowhere near and had nothing to do with my brand and my personal name and my likeness and all of the above still takes a major hit.”

In fact, he claims that he will never hold another Orange Crush Festival in Georgia again due to these issues. 

Strength of the Trademark

Trademarks are “a form of intellectual property that serve to identify the sources of goods.” They also “promise a consistent level of quality, whether it be good or bad.” By protecting the means sellers use to identify their goods, they protect both sellers and buyers. Buyers are protected from unscrupulous sellers tricking them into buying counterfeit goods, while sellers’ are protected from their reputations being sullied by the actions of others.

Infringement occurs when one good is likely to be confused with another. For example, a store selling “Apple” branded fruit is fine because it is not likely to be confused with the computer manufacturer. Meanwhile, “Apple” branded televisions are similar enough to computers that many people would likely confuse them for products by Apple Computers. Therefore, “Apple” Televisions would likely infringe on Apple’s trademarks.

Trademarks are “protectable only if they are distinctive [and]…are judged on a spectrum of distinctiveness; arbitrary and fanciful trademarks are considered to be the most distinctive.” Arbitrary and fanciful marks have nothing to do with the goods sold, similar to how the trademark Apple has nothing to do with actual fruit.  Suggestive marks suggest the goods, but the consumer still needs to use their imagination to figure out what the good is, like the airplane manufacturer Airbus. Descriptive marks describe the specific goods sold and they are weaker than the above categories, since they only describe the product. After all, many makers of similar products might describe their marks in similar ways. Therefore, consumers must associate the descriptive mark with the product for it to gain protection. Finally, the last level of distinctiveness are generic marks which describe a general class of goods and are therefore not protected by trademarks.

The Orange Crush Festival is an arbitrary mark because it does not describe, nor even suggest, a beachside festival. T This lack of direct association with the event’s theme enhances the distinctiveness of the mark, offering it robust protection under trademark law. Consequently, Mr. Turner’s rights to this festival name are exceptionally strong.

Due to this distinctiveness, other people or businesses using the name “Orange Crush Festival” for their events are very likely to confuse people. Since the name is clearly that of Mr. Turner’s festival, anyone else using it implies a connection to Mr. Turner. 

Not only are people likely to be confused, but, based on Mr. Turner’s comments, many already have been. His reputational problems stem from events he had no involvement with piggybacking on his good will. Once they are done, he is left to piggyback on the consequences of their actions.
Incidents like this underscore why trademark law exists. Mr. Turner is not suing for the fun of it. He is suing to protect his brand’s goodwill. Festival goers will also benefit from this because it will allowMr. Turner and those he authorizes to use the name, to ensure a quality experience at his standards. . Festival-goers deserve to know what sort of event they are getting when they go to the Orange Crush Festival, whether it meets or falls short of their expectations.

Your Squishmallow Isn’t Who You Think It Is: Setting The Bounds Of The Soft Toy Market 

By: Caroline Dolan

Squishmallows were introduced in 2017 and went viral on TikTok and Instagram during the Covid-19 pandemic in 2021. People fell in love with these affordable and huggable plushies that are available in more than 3,000 different characters. Their unique sizes and colors provide comfort and joy for all ages and even serve a niche of Squishmallow collectors. 

Trade Dress: The Look and Feel

Trademarks are “words, names, symbols, or devices” that are distinct, functional, and used in commerce to identify the source of a good. The Lanham Act provides federal protection over the good-will of such artistic creations from infringement, dilution, cybersquatting, and false advertising. It also protects consumers from being deceived by knock-off products. The Lanham Act also protects a product’s trade dress, which is “the commercial look and feel of a product or service that identifies and distinguishes the source of the product or service.” Similar to trademarks, trade dress can receive protection even without formal registration with the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office.  

To assert a trade dress infringement claim, a plaintiff must demonstrate that their product’s trade dress  (1) is distinctive; (2) is owned by the plaintiff; (3) is nonfunctional; and (4) that the defendant used the trade dress without consent in a way that is likely to confuse the ordinary consumer as to the source, sponsorship, or affiliation of the product. The Ninth Circuit has held that a trade dress that fails to be inherently distinctive may still be protected if it possesses a secondary meaning. To show a secondary meaning, a plaintiff must prove “a mental recognition in buyers’ and potential buyers’ minds that products connected with the [trade dress] are associated with the same source.” 

Build-A-Bear vs. Squishmallow

Warren Buffet’s investment company, Berkshire Hathaway, owns Alleghany Corporation which is the parent company of Jazwares LLC. Jazwares oversees Kelly Toys which is a leading toy manufacturer and the creator of Squishmallows. Squishmallows have seen its sales boom since 2021 and can be purchased in a variety of spaces, including in bulk at your local Costco. However, in January 2024, to offer “optimal hugging benefits” in light of Valentine’s Day, Build-A-Bear launched its Skoosherz line—a variety of collectible plush pillow-like toys. 

Once the Sckoosherz line was released, Kelly Toys promptly filed a lawsuit in the Central District of California claiming that Build-A-Bear’s Skoosherz line infringes on Squishmallow’s trade dress because Skoosherz imitate Squishmallows’ “shape, face style, coloring and fabric.” Kelly Toys’ complaint alleges that Skoosherz “have the same distinctive trade dress as the popular Squishmallows, including: shaped fanciful renditions of animals/characters; simplified Asian style Kawaii faces; embroidered facial features; distinctive and nonmonochrome coloring; and velvety velour-like textured exterior.” It asserts that these similarities seek to “trick consumers” and has harmed the Squishmallows brand by “divert[ing] sales and profits from Kelly Toys to Build-A-Bear.” Kelly Toys is seeking unspecified damages and an injunction to stop the sale of Skoosherz. In Kelly Toys’ view, Build-A-Bear is intentionally copying the distinct physical characteristics and exterior appearance of Squishmallows to capitalize on Squishmallows’ international success.

Build-A-Bear has responded by filing its own complaint in the Eastern District of Missouri asserting that its Skoosherz line is merely an extension of its already existing line of animal toys. In Build-A-Bear’s view, Skoosherz merely imitates the popular plushies that Build-a-Bear has previously sold. For instance, Build-A-Bear claims that the Skoosherz Pink Axåolotl is merely an imitation of its original Pink Axolotl toy. The company is seeking a declaratory judgment stating that Skoosherz do not infringe on the Squishmallow trade dress and furthermore, that the Squishmallow trade dress is not even protectable under the Lanham Act. Build-A-Bear asserts that the Squishmallow trade dress lacks a consistent look and feel and shares characteristics with toys already present in the market. According to its complaint, “[i]f each aspect of the claimed trade dress were in fact protected trade dress, it would be virtually impossible for competitors to create alternative designs.”

Bearing a Squishy Future

Trade dress is a critical element of trademark law and serves to safeguard the goodwill of creators, the protection of consumers, and a competitive market. Although this dispute resides in the market of soft toys, it highlights a new perspective of trade dress law and application. If a jury trial is granted, Kelly Toys will likely rely on side-by-side comparisons to highlight the visual similarities between Squishmallows and Skoosherz as well as present consumer comments that have been made on Build-a-Bear’s social media account dubbing Skoosherz as “knockoff Squishmallows.” Although such evidence can support Kelly Toys’ infringement claims, it will still have the initial burden of proving that its trade dress is protectable.